
The debate over which high school gets more
coverage seems to flare up the most during
the girls soccer season.
One of the great debates of our time rages in saloons, on various local blogs and in the back of soccer vans in and around the Gem City.
"The Herald-Whig covers Quincy High School more than they do Quincy Notre Dame," one side yells.
"The Herald-Whig covers Quincy Notre Dame more than they do Quincy High School," the other counters.
It's a never-ending battle that was going on before I landed in here in 1997 and will rage long after I'm gone. For whatever reason(s), folks think we favor one school more than the other.
It's a battle we'll never win. All we can do is try to cover the schools as evenly as possible. It's not easy to satisfy everyone, especially when you consider 40-plus other high schools and four colleges in our coverage area who we need to write about this spring. Those schools have baseball, softball, track and tennis teams that would like some coverage as well.
At least since I've been here, it seems the debate fires up every soccer season — moreso during the girls season in the spring than with the boys in the fall.
An unsigned letter with no return address came to our office earlier this week. We'd never kill trees to run this letter in the print edition, but in cyberspace, it's fair game.
This, in part, is from a backer of Quincy Notre Dame's girls soccer team.
This letter actually should've been sent a week ago after once again QND girls soccer got a 3 line article after defeating Jeff City in the last 2 minutes. There wasn't anyone from the Whig of course because the QHS girls had a game.
After opening the Sunday paper this morning and seeing another large article of the QHS girls ... was very irritating. QND did not play this weekend but we have not gotten half of the coverage QHS has gotten!
The Whig did a preview article before the first game for QND. Then we got a picture article after our first game an the only other article that was decent size was when we BEAT QHS. Unfortunately the picture that you chose from that game was terrible. There had to be better pictures to choose from.
We beat Kirksville — 4-0 and got a 4-5 line article at the bottom of the page while QHS also played out of town that week and lost, and they got a third of a page article. QND is continually put under all the line scores. When we beat Jeff City last Saturday in the last 2 minutes, That should render a decent size article. Instead QHS boys baseball was on the front page after losing a doubleheader 8-0 and the QHS girls tied 1-1 and got another full sized article. They've had 6-7 full sized articles and have never been listed under a line score.
The QHS girls play in the Western Big 6 conference, which is a total joke. Those teams are terrible but still get coverage. Is the general rule that if both girls teams are in town QHS gets the coverage since your photographer has a daughter on the QHS team. I know for a fact that one of your writers is very PRO QHS.
I'm just asking for some fairness. Please evaluate the last month of coverage. Even though QND has played less games than QHS, they've gotten cheated from some very good games they've won. Our girls work just as hard as any other sports team.
Lastly, Is there ever a chance that either one of the girls soccer team would ever get anything on the FRONT page for a regular-season game?
P.S. QND plays a good Normal IL team Wed. Could we please get an article on a page that's noticable. Our fans would surely appreciate it and our Girls truly deserve it. Thanks for your time!
Here's a look at our QHS and QND girls soccer coverage to this point in the season, including games through April 16:
QND has played seven games, four of which the Herald-Whig has staffed. We have run QND stories on:
March 24 — Season preview (with picture), story appeared on page 1B
March 26 — Tie with Helias (pic), 1B
April 2 — Win over QHS (two pics), 1B
April 2 — Sidebar on Leigh McLaughlin (pic), 3B
April 4 — Win over Troy (pic), 1B
April 17 — Tie vs. Normal U-High (no pic), 1B
QHS has played nine games, six of which the Herald-Whig has staffed. We have run QHS stories on:
March 14 — Season preview (pic), 1B
March 22 — QHS tourney (pic), 5B
March 23 — QHS tourney (pic), 3B
March 30 — At Rock Island (no pic), 3B
March 31 — Brittany Senator feature (pic), 1B
April 2 — Loss to QND (pic), 1B
April 6 — Win over Moline (pic), 3B
April 13 — Win over Helias (pic), 3B
QHS holds an 8-6 story lead on QND right now, but that should turn over the next few weeks as QHS hits the road and QND actually plays a few more home matches. QND has just eight home matches this spring as opposed to 12 for QHS.
We likely will cover three more QHS matches this spring — two in their second tourney and the other QND match.
We likely will cover QND at least five more times. Two games at QHS tourney, two more at QND tourney and the second match with QHS. The Lady Raiders are also due a feature story before the second QHS match, which will appear on May 5.
When you add it all up, we will have covered nine QHS and nine QND matches this season. Each school will also have received a season preview story and one feature story during the season.
This wasn't the first complaint we've received this spring about our soccer coverage. A QND parent also asked about our coverage of the two schools. When given the information above, he understood how we did things a little better than he did before.
Unfortunately, people are always going to think we are a little biased in how we cover things. Yes, we do have a photographer whose daughter plays for QHS's girls soccer team. We also have an editor in our office whose daughter plays for QND's girls soccer team. Another reporter has a daughter who plays for the QHS girls basketball team. One of our sports writers has a nephew who played soccer and wrestled at QHS.
Most of the people who work at The Herald-Whig have families and children who participate in interscholastic sports or have done so in the past for both QHS and QND. Whether or not someone's child from the Herald-Whig is going to be in the event has no bearing on how we play or if we cover the story.
If you have a concern with how we cover things, I'm always more than willing to talk to readers about the problem. Feel free to call me at (800) 373-9444, ext. 13365, or directly at 221-3365. My e-mail address is dobrien@whig.com. My only request is that you identify yourself when you call or write. You know who I am, the least you can do is tell me who you are in return.
Let the debate continue.
Recent Comments